Get Started

Turn peak season returns into your best retention touchpoint

Author
Stord

Published Date
November 19, 2026

share

subscribe

Peak is right around the corner, and the returns that follow come with it. For the customer, that’s where the real test begins. They didn’t get what they wanted the first time, and how a brand handles what happens next decides whether they ever come back. Most brands treat that moment as a support ticket. Their customers treat it as a verdict.

71% of shoppers say a poor returns experience makes them less likely to buy again, and peak volume puts every weak spot under pressure. A clumsy return costs the price of processing it, plus the next order and the one after that. Brands that settle their returns policies before peak arrives protect both their margin and the customers they worked hard to win.

One painful returns experience can cost you the customer

Returns are one of the least modernized parts of the customer relationship. Stord’s 2025 Mystery Shopping Report found:

  • 12% Of brands have no formal returns policy

  • 36% Still make customers email support to start a return

  • 61% Of shoppers have already returned an online purchase

Every brand forcing customers through that friction teaches them to shop somewhere easier next time.

Where most returns platforms fall short

Most returns platforms sit at the edge of the operation, generating labels and issuing refunds. The real work of receiving, inspecting, and deciding what happens to each item takes place in the warehouse, where they can’t see. The portal knows a return was requested. It rarely knows what arrived, what condition it was in, or whether it should have been accepted at all.

That gap shows up in four ways:

  • Disconnected systems: Returns span channels and tools that don’t talk to each other, so the same return gets handled differently each time.

  • High cost, low control: Returns get approved without enforced policy, so invalid or avoidable ones pass through.

  • No visibility: Brands can’t see why items came back, so orders sit stuck as “Delivered,” refund automation breaks, and reporting drifts.

  • Manual handling: Approvals, labels, and tracking run on email and forms, which slows resolution and inflates support volume.

A portal can tell a customer a refund is coming. It can’t decide whether the returned item is worth restocking, liquidating, or throwing away, and that decision carries the real cost.

Returns are a six-figure line item

  • U.S. shoppers sent back roughly $850B in merchandise in 2025, with an estimated 19.3% of e-commerce purchases returned.

  • Each return costs $20–30 to process, counting reverse shipping, labor, inspection, and restocking.

  • A brand running 10,000 orders a month spends $456,000–684,000 a year on processing alone, before lost inventory value.

  • About 9% of returns are fraudulent or abusive, and every dollar of that fraud costs a brand $4.61 once the full downstream impact is counted.

Much of that spend never should have happened: fraud, plus valid returns a clear policy or enforced return window would have caught. The instinct is to remove every barrier, but a one-click refund with no policy behind it feels great to the customer and terrible to the P&L. The goal is to make the right call on each return, quickly and at the point where the cost lives, so honest customers still get a smooth experience.

Stop routing returns. Start resolving them.

The brands making real progress closed the distance between where a return is requested and where it’s resolved, so policy, processing, and refund run on the same facts. That’s the idea behind Stord Returns. Most returns platforms are portals that route requests to a warehouse they can’t see. Stord Returns runs natively inside the warehouse, on the same platform as Stord Order Management and Warehouse Management.

Cost recovery starts before the label prints

Eligibility rules apply at the point of request, catching invalid or abusive returns before they cost a label, shipment, or restock. Fees show before submission, and configurable policies let each brand decide what it will accept.

Full lifecycle tracking, from request to restocked

Every return is tracked from request through receiving, inspection, grading, and disposition, with order and warehouse data in sync. Inspection results drive the restock, liquidate, or dispose decision, and refunds trigger on time instead of orders sitting in limbo.

Self-service for shoppers, automation for operations

Shoppers start a return, pick a reason, and get a label or QR code without emailing support. Pay-on-use labels cost money only when scanned, and routing sends each item to the facility where it can be resold fastest.

One platform, one source of truth

Returns started anywhere land in a single system of record, with one data model and complete visibility across every channel and warehouse. Most returns tools can’t offer that because they were never inside the operation to begin with.

A refund isn’t the only outcome

Not every return should be returned.

For low-value items, the $20–30 to process a return routinely exceeds what the item is worth. Shipping a $12 product across the country, inspecting it, and restocking it is a guaranteed loss twice over, on the refund and on every warehouse touch. Without a way to weigh cost against value, every request becomes an approval.

Returnless Resolution, built into Stord Returns, turns that automatic yes into an economic decision. Brands set an item-value threshold, and below it the policy engine resolves the return in real time:

  • Refund or store credit issues instantly

  • No label, no warehouse touch, no inspection, and no restocking

  • The shopper keeps the item, and the outcome logs for reporting

Behavioral rules still run before any refund goes out, flagging abuse patterns, catching high-frequency returners by SKU, category, or order history, and routing flagged accounts to stricter review. Honest customers never feel it, and repeat claimants stop getting free merchandise.

Brands can also keep the revenue entirely. Exchanges let a customer swap size, color, or variant in the same return flow, and store credit turns a would-be refund into retained revenue. A refund sends the customer away with their money; an exchange or credit keeps them in the relationship.

Making returns a part of the customer experience

Brands have spent a decade optimizing every forward step of the customer journey, from the first ad to the unboxing. The return is the one stretch still running on systems never designed for it, absorbing hundreds of thousands of dollars a year while shaping whether a customer comes back.

Returns will always be part of selling online. Whether they keep leaking margin and goodwill or start protecting both comes down to one question: what happens to a return once it leaves the customer’s hands? Brands that can see that far, through receiving, inspection, and the decision about what comes next, turn their most expensive blind spot into something they control.

Stop absorbing return costs. Start recovering them. 

Talk to Stord: sales@stord.com | (833) 700-2025

More Articles

1/6

1/6